Car jack and jack stand failures can result from product defects, damage, wear or improper use. A collapse can trap or seriously injure someone beneath the vehicle. A jack raises a vehicle; appropriate support equipment is needed before work underneath. Never work under a vehicle supported only by a jack.
The 2020 Harbor Freight recall of more than 1.7 million Pittsburgh Automotive jack stands shows why product identification matters. However, a recall total is not a failure rate. The sections below explain what can go wrong, how to check equipment and what to preserve after a car jack accident.
Do jack stands fail, and how often does it happen?
Yes, jack stands can fail, but there is no single reliable failure percentage established by the sources cited here. Historical emergency-department injury estimates count injuries in a defined period, not the proportion of all stands that fail. They should not be presented as a current annual failure rate. A collapse may involve a defect, wear, incorrect engagement, overloading or unsuitable placement. The individual product and circumstances need investigation.
What is the difference between a car jack and a jack stand?
A car jack lifts a vehicle off the ground so it can be serviced or so a tire can be changed. A jack stand does not lift anything. It gives fixed, stable support after the vehicle has been raised. A jack is designed to lift, not to hold a vehicle in place for long, which is why safety guidance from tool makers and safety groups is consistent: never work under a vehicle supported only by a jack. Floor jacks, scissor jacks, bottle jacks and trolley jacks all fall into the same category.
What happens when a car falls off a jack?
A falling vehicle can cause crushing injuries, fractures, spinal cord injury, amputations or death. The actual vehicle weight and collapse mechanism matter; an average weight does not determine the injury or prove a product defect. Our team handles serious injury claims involving suspected lifting-equipment failures.
What should you do if a car falls off a jack?
If someone is trapped, call 911 immediately. Do not reach or crawl under the car to help, because it may still shift. Stay clear until trained responders arrive. If nobody is trapped, step away, keep everyone out from under the vehicle and have the jack and stands inspected before you use them again. See a doctor for any injury, even one that seems minor, and keep the jack, stands and packaging.

Why do car jacks and jack stands fail?
Some failures come from misuse. Using the equipment on soft or uneven ground, lifting at the wrong point on the vehicle, using a stand rated for less weight than the car, or skipping wheel chocks can all lead to a collapse. Worn or damaged equipment is another cause. Other failures are the fault of the product. A manufacturing defect, a weak weld, poor design, a hydraulic jack that loses pressure, or instructions and warnings that do not clearly explain how to use the product can make a jack or stand unsafe even when the user does everything right. A defect like this may go unnoticed until the moment the equipment fails.
Have jack stands been recalled? Are Harbor Freight jack stands safe?
In 2020, Harbor Freight recalled more than 1.7 million Pittsburgh Automotive 3 ton and 6 ton heavy duty steel jack stands. NHTSA tracked the recall as two campaigns: 20E016 for about 454,000 units produced from June 2013 to November 2019, and 20E027 for about 1,254,000 units produced from December 2012 to March 2020. The recalled stands are the 3 ton item numbers 61196 and 56371 and the 6 ton item number 61197, which you can find on the label. The manufacturer, Jiaxing Golden Roc Tools, determined the defect was due to aging production tooling, which could let the ratchet teeth engage the pawl inconsistently so that the stand could drop. NHTSA said injuries had been reported, and Harbor Freight reported 11 injury claims, none life threatening, and offered a gift card equal to the purchase price. Walmart also recalled nearly 14,000 Hyper Tough 2 ton jack stands in August 2020 for a similar ratchet bar problem. Our product recall lawyers follow recalls like these, including the YETI cooler recall and the Hyundai Santa Fe Sport engine fire recall.
How do I check if my jack stands are recalled?
Look for the item number and brand on the label, then search NHTSA’s recall site and CPSC.gov. For the Harbor Freight recall, the item number is on the yellow part of the label on the base of the 61196 and 61197 stands and on the top of the 56371 stands. You can also call the NHTSA Vehicle Safety Hotline at 888-327-4236. Stop using any stand that is recalled, bent, cracked, rusted or missing its pin or pawl.
Are Scissor Jacks Safe for Working Under a Car?
Do not treat a scissor jack as a substitute for appropriate vehicle supports. Follow the complete instructions for the exact jack and vehicle, including the permitted task, load rating and lift points. A supplied emergency jack may have a limited intended use. If the instructions are missing or the equipment’s suitability is uncertain, use a qualified professional rather than improvise a lifting arrangement.
If a car fell off a jack, the visible damage may not reveal every affected component. Keep clear of an unstable vehicle and have a qualified professional assess its condition before it is moved or driven. Preserve photographs and the equipment safely if a defect or injury needs investigation.
Can other lifting equipment fail too?
Yes. Floor jacks, scissor jacks, trolley jacks, portable lift systems and automotive lifts and hoists can all fail. These failures can come from design flaws, worn or poorly maintained parts, improper installation or inspection, or misuse. Failures in a commercial garage can also raise workplace safety issues, and our team also handles construction accident cases that involve lifting equipment such as pump jack scaffolds.
How can you use a car jack and jack stands safely?
Follow the vehicle and equipment manufacturers’ complete instructions, including approved lift and support points, capacity ratings and inspection requirements. Use the specified equipment on a firm, level surface and proper wheel chocks as instructed. Never work under a vehicle supported only by a jack, improvise supports or use damaged or recalled equipment. If you are unsure how to support the vehicle safely, have a qualified professional perform the work. Stay clear of an unstable vehicle and call emergency services if someone is trapped.
Can you sue if a car jack or jack stand failed?
A defective car jack or jack stand can fail even when you take every precaution. If a defect in design or manufacturing, or a failure to warn about known risks, caused your injury, you may have a product liability claim against the manufacturer, the distributor or the retailer. Claims can also follow a wrongful death when a person is killed. See our wrongful death lawyers for more information. If you were hurt, keep the jack or stand, the packaging, the receipt and any photos. Do not throw away or repair the equipment, since it is the most important evidence in the case. Our car jack and jack stand injury lawyers have the resources and experience to help victims of defectively designed or manufactured tools and equipment. To speak with an attorney, call 1-878-888-7878 or contact the Killino Firm.
What Else Should You Know About Car Jack and Jack Stand Failures?
Do jack stands fail? Yes. They can fail because of misuse, wear or defects.
What is the difference between a jack and a jack stand? A jack lifts the vehicle. A jack stand holds it once it is lifted. A jack is not designed to hold a vehicle while someone works under it.
Are Harbor Freight jack stands safe? In 2020, Harbor Freight recalled more than 1.7 million Pittsburgh Automotive 3 ton and 6 ton jack stands because a manufacturing defect could let the stand drop.
What should I do if a car falls off a jack? If anyone is trapped, call 911. Do not reach or crawl under the car. Stay clear until help arrives.
Can I sue if a jack or jack stand failed? You may have a product liability claim if a defect in design or manufacturing, or inadequate warnings, caused the failure. Keep the product and talk to a lawyer promptly.




